Fleischman: It’s Not Just Secret Meetings at OC Water District, Look at Pay for Meetings

I read with interest the recent Voice of Orange County story, “Water District’s Secretive Committees Likely Violate Open Meetings Law,” highlighting some potentially bad behavior on the part of public officials at the Orange County Water District.

Frankly, I am not surprised.  You see there is no real accountability in the system of obscure water districts large and small all over Orange County — because there is no real public awareness of or interest in what these special districts do — because their area of responsibility is so narrow and relatively obscure that getting on the radar of the public is — well, virtually impossible.

Oh sure, Directors appear on the ballot.

Yet no one really knows who these folks are or what they do.

Kind of like an election to the political party central committee, the factors that tend to influence who wins election to a water board are ballot placement (first on the ballot?), ballot title, and then how many “slate cards” you buy on to — these being commercial endeavors that for the most part are available to the first or highest bidder.

My criticism is of most all water districts, all of whom toil away in obscurity, with a system that has little public accountability.  Well, guess what happens when  mom and dad aren’t watching?

You guessed it — everyone puts their hands into the cookie jar.

While most (not all) water districts offer full-time benefits for part time work — the Orange County Water District (which I use as an example because they are featured in the recent Voice of OC story) has a really outrageous get-rich scheme going on for it’s nine board members.

OCWD Per Diem

First of all — being an “elected” Board Member of a water district is a part time endeavor.  There are a few meetings to attend each month, but a part time position means that it is presumed you do something else for a living, or are retired or I guess have very few expenses (maybe you live with your parents, or your children?).

For this part time work — board members are taking home in most cases over $15k a year and in some cases over $25k in direct pay.

Well that sounds part time.

Except that this district then heaps the benefits package of their full time employees onto these lucky nine lottery winners.

What does that look like?

It’s Cadillac health care benefits for themselves AND their dependents (of course board members can “opt out” for big cash payments instead, courtesy of rate-payers.)

But wait, there’s more.

These part-time politicians also get retirement benefits!

Yes, you read that right — payments are made into a board member’s very-own 401(k) style retirement account — for some it’s a couple thousand a year, for others it’s three or four thousand bucks more – tax free.

What a great gig.

But we’re not done yet.

These part-timers also get life and accidental death or dismemberment insurance, with the ability to buy more.

And as if all of this isn’t enough, they all can get an “electronic equipment allowance” of up to $1,290 per year.

Translation — the lucky 9 lotto winners can go out and get a top of the line iPad or computer, the kind they would have anyways, but then have rate-payers pay for it.  What a deal.

To say nothing of the fact that some of these folks serve on other boards, or are even full time government employees, double or triple dipping into the benefits trough at the expense of taxpayers and rate-payers.

Of course these ten water board members with one vote could actually end all of this lavish self-dealing, and perhaps just take the reasonable monthly stipend.  But they have no reason to do so because no one is guarding the hen house from these foxes.

Just who are these ten OCWD board members?

Former Garden Grove Councilmember Dina Nguyen, Denis Bilodeau (see below), Roger Yoh, former Supervisor Philip Anthony (who has been serving since 1981), Stephen Sheldon, former Huntington Beach Councilmember Cathy Green, Shawn Dewane, Santa Ana Councilmember Roman Reyna, Fullerton Councilmember Jan Flory and Anaheim Councilmember Jordan Brandman.  (You’ll also see former Anaheim Councilman Harry Sidhu on the compensation list, but he was replaced by Brandman late last year.)

My favorite “triple dipper” is Bilodeau, who has a full time position as Chief of Staff to Supervisor Shawn Nelson for which he handsomely compensated $160,000 a year.

On top of that he also serves as a part-time staffer to Nelson, paid $39,000 annually from the AQMD (so he’s full time, then part time).

Then he has his service on the water district, as discussed in this piece, with benefits gives him nearly $45,000 (if you have a calculator he’s at nearly $250,000 in taxpayer compensation annually – but I’m sure taxpayers are getting they moneys worth).  He use to be a quadruple dipper as he also concurrently served on the Orange City Council, but termed out last year.

And so then when an article comes out calling into question the practices of OCWD board members, I just assume that they are doing bad things.

Because if they can’t see the immorality of enriching themselves with full-time benefits for part-time work, then their judgement is flawed.

Of course it’s never too late for these folks to step off of the gravy train.  But I won’t hold my breath.

Jon Fleischman is publisher of the Flash Report.

Voice of OC is interested in hearing different perspectives and voices. If you want to weigh in on this issue please contact Voice of OC Involvement Editor Theresa Sears at TSears@voiceofoc.org

  • John Claxton

    His name is Denis Billsomedough! Worst offender in County history. Nelson is his current enabler and accomplice. The system is very broken. His children will be reading his stories of grand theft as he hopefully rots in a prison cell some day. I’m optimistic!

  • Josh McIntosh

    Well I have never seen some of them (Nguyen and Brandman) even make a comment, ask a question or do anything to earn their place at the table. No participation at all. This leads me to assume their only reason for being there is to make a yes vote for Poseidon.

    • Rivett

      Well, that and the $250.

  • Antonella Moreno

    Look even farther…The ex CM of Brea was recently under investigation for payments he received from water companies. The DA decided it was better handled by the FPPC instead of the courts. Funny how when they catch them, they release them!!!

  • Nrgmavn

    It isn’t a monthly stipend. It is a per meeting stipend. $250 per meeting with a limit of 10 per month (one stipend per day and a loose definition of “meeting”). Most meetings last less than an hour. Jan Flory tried to get the board to consolidate meetings but that would mean a pay cut so the majority voted that down. The savings would have covered the cost of video streaming meetings (as little as $12,000/year), another item that Jan Flory put forward. But the majority piled on with a heap of arrogant reasons opposing it, like “no one would watch.” Yep, voters get exactly what they deserve at every level of government.

    • RyanCantor

      Well, good for Jan Flory for attempting to get the people’s business done.

    • David Zenger

      Yeah, per meeting. And you can bet the farm they get paid whether they sit through the whole thing or not.

      • occynic

        Bilodeau had a major problem with that a few years ago when it looked like he was getting paid for meetings he didn’t attend…..showing up for 5 minutes won’t get you in the minutes.

  • David Zenger

    Yep. All pretty sad. And mostly allegedly “conservative” Republicans.

    Bilodeau was also getting stipends from the Sanitation District and the Vector Control Board and who knows what all else.

    • occynic

      For his last few years in office he was the only member of the Orange City Council getting paid.