Opinion

Press release

Voice of OC Collegiate News Service logo

Tustin’s current city council and mayor are set to appoint city council members to different committees representing Tustin tonight, a duty incoming Mayor Letitia Clark says is being taken from her before she is sworn in.

Outgoing Mayor Austin Lumbard and city council members are scheduled to vote on which council members will be elected to different boards such as the OC Fire Authority Board of Directors, while also establishing a new standing Veteran’s Advisory Committee.

Mayor Lumbard did not respond to a request for comment on Tuesday. 

The move, usually reserved for the incoming mayor, is being heavily criticized by Clark and social media comments. 

In a video posted to Instagram, Clark said the appointments were traditionally held during the second council meeting of December, making the move a break from a nearly 100 year-old tradition.

“Changing a long-standing practice before a new administration is sworn in brings about issues of fairness, respect for the voters and transparency.” Clark said in the Nov. 16 video. 

“And it’s not about who gets a seat at the table, it’s about who gets a voice. A rule shouldn’t change just because the leadership is changing.”

As of Monday, voting results showed Clark in the lead with an estimated 51.8% of the vote, leaving Lumbard to trail behind with an estimated 48.2% of the vote. 

In general-law cities, state law gives the elected mayor the power to make all appointments on who sits on different boards, committees and commissions with city council approval.  

According to a Tustin staff report, Lumbard requested for city staff to place item 13 on the Nov. 17 agenda to “approve changes to the appointments to the Regional committees on which members of the City Council will serve and Mayor-appointments to City Council Ad Hoc committees.”

The item, if approved by city council, would not only approve the establishment of a new advisory committee, but approve the appointment of Councilman Ray Schnell to the OC Fire Authority Board of Directors, replacing Lumbard – who has been on the board since 2022. 

As of Monday, voting results showed Schnell leading opponent Thomas James Reed with an estimated 58.5% of the vote, leaving Reed with an estimated 41.5% of the vote. 

In a statement given by Clark to the Voice of OC Tuesday, she said the appointments provide the mayor an opportunity to work collaboratively with city council members and understand their interests and expertise on different issues in the city. 

She says accelerating the decision strips that opportunity away from her.

“By accelerating these appointments before I take office, the outgoing mayor is effectively denying the incoming mayor the opportunity to participate in decisions that will shape our city’s representation during my administration,” Clark wrote. “It also potentially prevents me from serving on regional boards where I believe I could make a meaningful contribution, including the Orange County Fire Authority.”

Lumbard is also expected to appoint Schnell and Councilman John Nielson to the new Veterans Advisory Committee, along with Tustin American Legion Post 227 representative Mike Lopez, Tustin Veterans Outpost representative Derick Burton and as well as three at-large veteran members. 

Other appointments include former Councilwoman and OC Board of Education Member Beckie Gomez as the Tustin representative for the OC Mosquito and Vector Control Board of Trustees. 

She resigned from the role of Board of Education Trustee in 2022 after a lawsuit was filed against her for serving on the education board and on city council at the same time. 

Clark says the question she would ask the outgoing mayor and city council is: “If this is such an important decision for the future of Tustin, why shouldn’t the mayor elected by the people have a voice in making it?”

Sara Leon is a Voice of OC reporting fellow. You can reach her at admin@voiceofoc.org

Sara Leon joined Voice of OC as a summer intern in 2026 from Cal State Fullerton. Leon started in journalism at Fullerton College’s student newspaper, The Hornet, before transferring to Cal State...