Opinion

Press release

Voice of OC Collegiate News Service logo

Santa Ana taxpayers have spent at least $8 million in legal expenses and to settle legal claims and lawsuits against the police department in the past six years.

Most of the legal payouts stem from car crashes and excessive force claims.

The payouts come as voters in the city are on track to approve a ballot measure to indefinitely keep a 1.5% sales tax increase that was supposed to expire in 2039 after elected city officials struggled with a structural deficit, cutting about $11 million in spending to balance their budget. 

Last week, the city’s police oversight commission received a report with little discussion on the over 83 police-related claims officials have paid out between 2020 and October 2026 at the request of Commissioner Carlos Perea this past summer. 

To view the list of payouts, click here. 

Perea said a report like this should be made annually and shared with the city council.

“It’s better to have this be released periodically rather than just having to wait until someone does that,” he said at Thursday’s Police Oversight Commission meeting. 

Police Chief Robert Rodriguez said they will continue to evaluate their operations and take proactive steps to reduce liability risks and said he mandated officers to take emergency vehicle training which wasn’t previously required.

“We learn from every incident, regardless of whether it results in a complaint of service, a lawsuit, or neither. That includes reviewing our policies, training, supervisory practices, and decision-making. We welcome any opportunity to provide additional training to our employees,” he wrote in a Friday email.

Rodriguez also said it’s also important to continue training on de-escalation.

“When opportunities exist to strengthen our training, we embrace them. While we cannot eliminate every incident or potential claim, we can take meaningful steps to reduce their frequency and severity. My expectation is that we remain proactive rather than reactive, learn from our experiences, and continually improve how we serve our community,” he wrote.

The report comes more than a month after Santa Ana officials faced demands for police accountability over the viral violent arrest of resident Florentino Lopez – the latest call for accountability in a city often plagued by concerns over police use of force. 

The $8 million spent in the past six years is about a third of what Santa Ana taxpayers spent on police payouts between 2011 and 2020 — roughly $24 million. 

Amid the six year period, Santa Ana’s ruling council majority – including three politicians backed by the police union – approved a three-and-half year $27 million contract with the police officers association expected to end next summer.

Those three politicians are on track to lose their election bids this year to progressive-backed candidates likely to take a more critical look at police policies, with Mayor Valerie Amezcua and Councilman Phil Bacerra set to lose reelection and Councilman David Penaloza conceding in 68th State Assembly District race last week.

At the same time, all the other two police union-backed candidates in the city council races are set to lose as well after the union spent over $270,000 to support the campaigns of their preferred candidates. 

Santa Ana Police Officers Association President John Kachirisky deferred most questions to the police department and that police officers have all graduated from a Police Officers Standards and Training certified academy.

Kachirisky also said K-9 officers take home police cars to transport and properly for their police dogs – a policy they support the department continuing. 

The Liability Cost of Santa Ana PD

According to the report, one of the highest pay outs in the last six years was for an excessive force use of a taser and assault and battery incident in 2022 that the city paid out $2.2 million to settle and resolved in 2025.

Many of the pay outs are related to police car collisions while others pay outs are for police shootings and alleged false arrests. 

Earlier this year, police officials publicly reported to the police oversight committee Santa Ana taxpayers paid out over $5 million since 2019 in lawsuits and claims from over 50 police car crashes – some of which stemmed from vehicle pursuits.

Last month, Voice of OC filed a public records request asking for a list of all legal settlements & pay outs related to the police department & use of force since 2020 & all legal claims/lawsuits associated with them.

As of the morning of Nov. 12, the city has released seven settlement agreements and 12 of the claims and complaints to the Voice of OC including the claim that resulted in a $2.2 million settlement.

According to the claim, Santa Ana Police officers responded to a call at La Quinta Inn in April, 2022 and allegedly tased a man and tackled him to the ground in one of the motel rooms before “multiple officers then improperly restrained” him “in a prone position for several minutes” resulting in his death.

In another claim filed in 2022, claimant Allen Cates alleged a police officer harassed him while eating Orange Chicken outside a Panda Express before allegedly throwing him violently to ground, breaking his arm and arresting him.

City officials agreed in 2024 to spend $550,000 in taxpayer dollars to settle the case. 

Hosam Elattar is a Voice of OC reporter. Contact him at helattar@voiceofoc.org.

Hosam Elattar is a Voice of OC/ Report For America reporter covering Anaheim & North Orange County, food insecurity, housing & homelessness, the Arab & Muslim American community and education. Elattar...