• Donate
  • Subscribe
  • logo
  • logo
  • Cities
    • Anaheim
    • Fullerton
    • Garden Grove
    • Irvine
    • Laguna Niguel
    • Mission Viejo
    • Santa Ana
    • Westminster
  • Topics
    • 2018 Elections
    • Countywide
    • County Government
    • Healthy Communities
    • Housing & Homelessness
    • Immigration
    • On OC Podcast
    • Politics
    • Public Safety
    • Transportation
    • Youth Media
  • Opinion
    • Community Columnists
    • Norberto Santana, Jr. columns
  • About
    • About Us
    • Board of Directors
    • Donate
    • Financial Disclosures
    • Inside the Newsroom
    • Our Donors
    • Our Staff
  • Donate
  • Subscribe
  • TRENDING TOPICS:
  • On OC Podcast
  • Santa Ana District Elections
  • 2018 Elections
opinion

Loewen: Anaheim Elementary School Board Has Opportunity for Redemption at Palm Lane

File photo by MARK RIGHTMIRE, ORANGE COUNTY REGISTER/SCNG

The Anaheim Elementary School District board will vote on a proposal to convert Palm Lane Elementary School into a charter school on Wednesday evening, Dec. 13. (File photo by MARK RIGHTMIRE, ORANGE COUNTY REGISTER/SCNG)

By Robert Loewen | December 11, 2017
3 Shares
Share3
Tweet
Email

On December 13, the Anaheim Elementary School District can redeem its past behavior by approving New Century as the charter school operator of Palm Lane School. In January, 2015, parents of 332 students at Palm Lane Elementary School submitted signed petitions to the AESD under California’s Parent Trigger Law because the school had posted failing student outcomes for over a decade. The district, more loyal to the status quo than improving student outcomes, sued the parents to block their attempt to transform Palm Lane into a charter school.

The district lost that litigation, but in the meantime, Palm Lane School did not improve. According to data provided by the state, 82.73 percent of Palm Lane students in 2017 failed to meet grade level in English Language Arts (fewer than 20 percent are reading at grade level), and 86.95 percent failed to perform at grade level in math.

The district should be embarrassed by its behavior as found by the trial court. In response to the Parent Trigger petition, the district established a “defective practice” in which “valid signed petitions were not counted,” and then it accused parents of not having enough valid signatures. The trial court also found that the district engaged in “feigned and contrived ignorance” of the identity of lead parents in order to claim that petitioners had not complied with a technicality in the law that required disclosure of lead parents. Rejecting these falsehoods, the trial court ordered the AESD to proceed with the trigger petition, and the appellate courts affirmed on these and other grounds.

That’s where we are now. Under the law, petitioning parents selected New Century to operate Palm Lane as a charter school. Almost immediately, a misinformation campaign began against New Century by word of mouth in which parents were informed that New Century would charge extra to attend Palm Lane charter, weed out low-performing students, not offer special education, speech therapy or other services that are legally required, and not provide credentialed teachers, none of which is true. This misinformation has been repeated in phone calls to parents by persons who say they represent the district. The district denies knowledge about this misinformation campaign, but one wonders how the callers were able to target parents of Palm Lane without access to district records.

Under the law, the district’s board must approve New Century before Palm Lane charter can open, but that should be a no brainer since the track record and reputation of New Century’s leadership makes it likely that student outcomes will improve at Palm Lane as soon as it takes over. It appears that staff will recommend approval, giving the school board a chance to redeem itself. The hearing on the New Century approval is December 13 at Anaheim Elementary School Board headquarters. The public should come to support the brave parents of Palm Lane.

Robert Loewen is chairman emeritus of the Lincoln Club of Orange County.

Opinions expressed in editorials belong to the authors and not Voice of OC.

Voice of OC is interested in hearing different perspectives and voices. If you want to weigh in on this issue or others please contact Voice of OC Involvement Editor Theresa Sears at TSears@voiceofoc.org

 

SUPPORT VOICE OF OC

Your donation to Voice of OC enables our reporters and editors to shine a spotlight on critical quality of life issues impacting communities across Orange County. We believe passionately in seeking truth, holding people in power accountable and enabling vibrant debate.


FILED UNDER:
  • Opinion
  • Anaheim Elementary School District
  • charter schools
  • New Century
  • opinion
  • Palm Lane School
  • Robert Loewen

DAILY HEADLINES NEWSLETTER

RELATED STORIES

  • Coleman and Williams: Support for Integrated Housing Campus in Irvine Grows

    By Anita Coleman, Ph.D and Wendy Williams | April 18, 2018

    Anita Coleman and Wendy Williams are the creators of Irvine for Everyone (I4E), a growing movement and group of Irvine residents and voters who support the creation of a full spectrum of housing in Irvine. The personal story of Wendy Williams, a 30 year resident of Irvine makes clear why it is important for Irvine to be a welcoming city and provide emergency shelters.

  • Loewen: Time to End Political Polarization

    By Robert Loewen | October 20, 2017

    Robert Loewen, chairman emeritus and former president of Orange County’s Lincoln Club, writes that the nation’s DREAM act kids need a legislative solution from Congress on immigration. Loewen writes these kids deserve consideration and the Lincoln Club’s heart is with them along with legislation that would allow them to stay in the United States and continue productive lives.

DISCUSSION

You can make your voice heard by commenting below. To ensure a vibrant and civil discussion, comments must follow Voice of OC's discussion policy.

Voice of OC

  • Voice of OC
  • About
  • Archives
  • Contact
  • Staff
  • Financial Disclosures

© Copyright 2018, Voice of OC

Voice of OC is a member of the Institute for Nonprofit News

Built with the Largo WordPress Theme from the Institute for Nonprofit News.

Back to top ↑