Two Orange County Supervisors are pushing for more transparency and details on how the county sheriff’s department turns over freshly released inmates to Immigration and Customs Enforcement – an issue local activist groups have loudly decried.
They also called for protections against any potential violations of constitutional rights by having the public defender’s office get involved in the transfers.
There’s been a 1,200% increase in people that were turned over to ICE last year, according to OC Sheriff officials.
During Tuesday’s public meeting, OC Supervisor Vicente Sarmiento said while it’s important to ensure people breaking the law are held accountable, the community needs more details over what the sheriff was doing to assist ICE.
“When you have a segment of the community that feels threatened in addition to having their communities subject to these deportations, we certainly feel there is a disconnect there, and it creates a level of distrust,” Sarmiento said. “The information is not always as clear as we’d like it to be from ICE.”
State law prohibits law enforcement officials from cooperating with ICE to turn over people who’ve been convicted of low-level crimes, like misdemeanors.
Supervisor Katrina Foley also backed up Sarmiento’s request, noting she wanted to see some more transparency before next year’s report.
“If there’s other data sets that this board would like to see, I’d be more than happy to make them available,” OC Sheriff Don Barnes said. “We want to make sure everyone knows they can call and expect help without regard to one’s immigration status.”
Only Foley and Sarmiento – two Democratic supervisors – spoke on the issue Tuesday.
Supervisors suggested the public defender’s office get involved in the transfers, with Sarmiento raising constitutional concerns about an inmate getting transferred to ICE officials upon their release from the county jail.
“Having somebody transferred … could constitute a new arrest, and also could require probable cause,” Sarmiento said. “That is a Fourth Amendment protection, that is something that would, with the use of a judicial warrant, could be addressed better.”
Sarmiento also said he thought the county should reexamine its relationship with ICE, but admitted that it was unlikely to happen.
Transfers Face Routine Pushback From Activists
County supervisors are required by law to discuss the issue at least once a year, giving residents an annual peek at who gets sent to immigration and who doesn’t.
Every year, local activists come out and call for the sheriff’s department to stop notifying ICE when they have someone in custody who’s been flagged by immigration authorities, noting that communities like Little Saigon were heavily impacted.
“Under your watch in Little Saigon, Santa Ana, Westminster, Garden Grove, over the last eight years we’ve seen the most transfers from your cities,” said Carlos Perea, executive director for the Harbor Institute for Immigrant and Economic Justice, to Supervisor Andrew Do.
“Your last year is going to be remembered by that record,” he continued. “The highest Vietnamese elected official in the county, and under your leadership you had the highest transfer of Vietnamese people to ICE.”
Do didn’t speak during Tuesday’s discussion.
Barnes said he’s following the law by notifying federal officials there were people to pick up, pointing out it was up to ICE who they took and highlighting that many of the people were arrested for crimes like kidnapping, drug trafficking, domestic violence and more.
“Change in numbers is not reflective of more or less action by law enforcement. We simply do what the law allows,” Barnes said. “I do not determine the demographics … they (inmates) either objectively meet the criteria, or they do not.”
He also pointed out that one group wasn’t getting talked about – the victims of crimes.
“I understand the passion,” Barnes said, referencing over a dozen activists calling for an end to deportations, “But none of the speakers spoke about the victims of the offenses and the victims of the original crimes.”
State law blocks the sheriff’s department from directly transferring inmates to Immigrations and Customs Enforcement, more commonly known as ICE.
But that doesn’t stop the department from notifying federal authorities when they release someone from custody who’s a repeat or violent offender so they can be immediately picked up by immigration in front of the jail.
The rules explicitly state inmates cannot be turned over if they were arrested for a misdemeanor.
“In no case shall cooperation occur pursuant to this section for individuals arrested, detained, or convicted of misdemeanors that were previously felonies,” the manual states.
To read the full manual, click here.
Last year, 221 people were released from the county jail directly into ICE’s custody, an increase from just 17 the year before according to a report released by the sheriff’s department.
Barnes told supervisors he has no control over whether ICE picks people up outside the county jail, and that there were over 200 inmates he didn’t refer to ICE and dozens of other people he did notify immigration about that they chose not to pick up.
When asked about the issue, ICE spokesman Richard Beam wasn’t able to provide a reason for the increase either.
“Enforcement and Removal Operations (ERO) Los Angeles does not keep specific data to explain the increase in the number of non-citizens taken into ERO custody in Orange County,” Beam wrote in a statement.
Beam also suggested several possible reasons for the shift, like how much a law enforcement department cooperates with ICE and what crimes occur.
But many of the details on who was arrested and released to ICE’s custody didn’t come directly from the sheriff’s department – they came from the Harbor Institute for Immigrant and Economic Justice, a nonprofit which obtained the data by filing public records requests to the sheriffs.
Their records showed that around 40% of the people turned over to ICE last year were Vietnamese, while another 43% were Mexican, with the remaining nationalities all falling at less than 10%.
Most of the people were arrested in Garden Grove, Westminster or Santa Ana.
When Voice of OC reporters asked for those details from the sheriff’s department, they were referred to the public records department.
Noah Biesiada is a Voice of OC reporter and corps member with Report for America, a GroundTruth initiative. Contact him at nbiesiada@voiceofoc.org or on Twitter @NBiesiada.











