Opinion

Press release

Voice of OC Collegiate News Service logo

This story has been updated to include campaign contribution data from 2025 in addition to contributions from 2026.

Following years of controversy surrounding Mission Viejo City Council elections — including officials illegally extending their terms, attempting to fight off election districts and finding themselves in court — the entire city council will be listed on the ballot this year.

After this year’s election establishes staggered terms, Mission Viejo will finally return to a standard election cycle that falls in line with the rest of the county.

And the city is guaranteed to get at least three new council members as incumbents term out.

For this year’s general election, Mission Viejo council Districts 1, 3 and 5 will be elected for a standard four-year term.

To create staggered elections, council Districts 2 and 4 will be elected to serve two-year terms. Then, in 2028, all council seats will return to four-year terms.

Who’s Running? 

This year, in District 1, incumbent Bob Ruesch is running against Kristen Wilcox, a writer.

Reusch has raised over $16,000 toward his campaign, according to his disclosure forms, including $5,900 from the CA Real Estate PAC. 

Wilcox filed a Form 470, meaning she received less than $2,000 in contributions.

In District 2, two newcomers are running against each other — Saga Conroy and Peter Molinari. 

Conroy currently serves on the city’s community services commission and works as community outreach director for Orange County Supervisor Don Wagner. Molinari is a small business owner and currently serves on the city’s planning and transportation commission.

Conroy has received over $24,000 in campaign funding this year, according to her campaign disclosure forms, including $5,900 from the CA Real Estate PAC and $6,000 from the Republican Party of Orange County. Last year, she received over $100,000 in contributions.

Molinari has raised over $23,000 in campaign contributions, with $5,900 coming from the Orange County Professional Firefighters Association PAC and $5,900 from the CA Real Estate PAC.

In District 3, incumbent Cynthia Vasquez is running against Bryan Zahn, a retired senior public services supervisor for the city.

According to their campaign disclosure forms, Vasquez has raised just over $22,000, including $5,000 from the Canyon Democrats, $1,000 from the Democratic Women of South Orange County and $1,250 from the Women in Leadership PAC. 

Zahn has raised over $38,000, including $5,900 from the Orange County Professional Firefighters Association PAC.

District 4 is also guaranteed to get a new councilmember as newcomers Laura Lacko and James Morrison vie for that seat.

Lacko is a community volunteer who has raised nearly $12,000 toward her campaign, including contributions from the Canyon Democrats, the Women in Leadership PAC and the Planned Parenthood of Orange and San Bernardino Counties Community Action Fund PAC. 

Morrison is a human resources professional who raised just over $13,000, including $5,900 from the Orange County Professional Firefighters Association PAC.

District 5 has only one candidate running unopposed: Steven Thornton, a defense acquisition contractor who also serves on the city’s community services commission. He’s raised just under $5,000 in campaign contributions.

To read each candidate’s statement, click here.

Cathy Palmer, a Mission Viejo resident, said this year is a unique opportunity to see new voices and perspectives elected to the council.

She’s lived in the city since 1989 and has been closely tuned in to the city council since 2018.

“Because three of the five members are termed out, it’s actually a chance to rejuvenate the council and get some fresh perspectives from people from the outside,” Palmer said in a Monday phone interview. “For a long time, like many small-ish cities, Mission Viejo was run by a fairly small, almost inbred community of people who all knew each other and all agreed with each other.”

“That generation is aging out, and I think that this election is a chance for us to truly get some fresh voices and fresh perspectives on the council and look at city priorities and how the city spends its money.”

Mission Viejo’s Controversial Election History

City leaders have been grappling with how to host elections for years after putting up a fight against creating election districts, a trend that’s spread across Orange County and the entire state in recent history.

Election districts break cities into regions, where candidates can only run in the district where they live and voters can only vote for the candidate that would represent their home’s geographic district boundary.

It’s the result of several legal challenges against local governments that have claimed at-large voting disenfranchises minority voters, adding that district-based elections help certain groups elect a candidate that better represents their community’s interests.

In an at-large election system, every resident can vote for every city council candidate listed on the ballot. That means that if there’s three seats up for election, then every registered voter in the city gets to weigh in on all three of those races.

In a district election system, voters can only vote for a single candidate that’s running in the district where they live, regardless of how many open seats there are.

Mission Viejo leaders attempted to argue that district-based elections weren’t going to help minority residents elect their preferred candidate because they claimed that different community groups were spread out across the city — not congregated in a certain region.

Instead, the city tried to pursue a different type of voting system known as cumulative voting. That system, which isn’t used by any general law cities in the state, allows residents to distribute multiple votes among their top-choice candidates. 

For example, if three seats are available in a cumulative voting system, residents could distribute three votes in any way they choose, including giving all of their votes to a single candidate or splitting them up between multiple candidates.

But that idea was ultimately rejected by then Secretary of State Alex Padilla since the voting system isn’t approved by the state legislature.

The council also came under fire for illegally extending terms for multiple officeholders.

When three councilmembers were supposed to term-out in 2020 — Wendy Bucknum, Ed Sachs and Greg Raths — they voted to stay on the council for another two years, claiming that since the cumulative voting efforts failed, they were required to serve four-year terms despite promising that they would only serve two years when they were elected in 2018.

While Bucknum, Sachs and Raths were supposed to be thrown off the dais in 2022, the California Appellate Court delayed that order a day before they were supposed to resign. An Orange County Superior Court Judge ultimately ordered all five Mission Viejo City Council members to stand for election in November 2022.

Now the entire council is up for reelection again as the city attempts to get back on a normal election schedule.

Palmer and other residents tried to get the city on an election schedule where three seats would be listed in presidential election years and two seats would be listed for midterm election years.

But council members instead voted to stagger elections in a way that will see a majority of seats on the ballot for midterm election years, when voter turnout is historically weaker.

“This is our chance to get more people to vote in local elections, this is our chance to actually change the pattern so that we have three seats up in the presidential and two seats up in the midterm,” Palmer said about that council vote from last year. “Of course, our voices weren’t listened to, or at least that’s how it feels to me.”

She said she wants new council members to take a look at the city’s priorities and how taxpayer dollars are being spent to ensure they’re representing residents’ wants and needs.

“It’s great to have nice parks. It’s wonderful that Mission Viejo supports a lot of community events, and I don’t think anyone objects to that,” she said. 

“But could some of that money be used for after school programs? Are there other programs and services that the city could support more robustly if they had perhaps a younger demographic who’s been through what it’s like to try to get childcare?” 

​​Angelina Hicks is the Voice of OC Collegiate News Service Editor. Contact her at ahicks@voiceofoc.org or on Twitter @angelinahicks13.

Angelina Hicks is Voice of OC’s Collegiate News Service editor, leading the newsroom’s partnership with Chapman University that gives students the chance to report on civic news across Orange County. Hicks...