City officials along Orange County’s idyllic coastline are scrambling for sand and measures to protect the shoreline ahead of what experts say could be a super El Niño this year that could supercharge coastal erosion.
It comes after the coast was battered last month by a series of swells from Hurricane Marie, triggering a state of emergency from several local cities all the way to the governor’s office as sand was swept out to sea.
While some cities were able to fast track new sand to their shores, others are desperately searching for a way to beef up their beaches amid warnings of a super El Niño storm this winter that’s expected to reshape the coastline.
San Clemente holds some of the barest beaches in the county, and city officials are starting to face questions from residents on why their coastline looks so different from many of their neighbors like Newport Beach – which is getting expedited sand replacement.
Why is San Clemente’s Beach so Damaged?
City officials acknowledged not enough attention has been paid to the sand issue at an informal gathering over the weekend when dozens of residents and activists heard from the city’s shoreline problems.
At a park just off the coast on Saturday, City Manager Andy Hall noted that over the prior decades, the city hadn’t prioritized replenishing their beaches the way other cities had, and they’re now paying the price.
“We haven’t been as aggressive as we probably should’ve been,” Hall said, calling it an “existential” threat.
While battling coastal erosion, city leaders have also grappled with the Pacific Surfliner rail that runs up the coast, which the OC Transportation Authority has repeatedly protected through the use of rocks that helped shield the tracks and shredded the city’s sand along the coast.
It’s a reality San Clemente residents see every day, watching their coast shrink over the past decade to the point that city officials have had to block off paths to the beach because they no longer lead to sand, just rock.

In an interview on Saturday, Hall said that the OC Transportation Authority has to get more aggressive about bringing sand to the beach.
“I hope they’re going to push as hard on getting sand on the beach as they have been to get rocks on the revetment,” Hall said. “I think OCTA needs to be the ones screaming for sand. I think they’re starting to, but I think they need to raise their voice and start saying ‘we would prefer to have sand than rock.’”
The authority’s board met on Monday and didn’t talk much about the need for sand or rocks as they approved an emergency measure to try and get both more sand and rocks on the beach, despite currently being on year two of a four year process to get sand on the beach.
San Clemente Councilman Victor Cabral also noted on Saturday that he wants to see OCTA “remediate” much of the damage caused by the rocks along the coast in the future.
What’s the Proposed Fix for San Clemente’s Beaches?
This November, San Clemente voters are set to decide on a new sales tax measure dubbed Measure M.
A ballot initiative written by San Clemente local Cameron Cosgrove, it would implement an additional 1% sales tax for a decade, the proceeds of which would be split between purchasing sand and helping fireproof the city if approved by over 50% of the voters in November.
At the Saturday event, Cosgrove noted the city’s current sand deficit is between two to four million cubic yards, which according to the city would add around 100 feet to the beach’s width, and that one time drop offs of a couple thousand cubic yards wouldn’t fix it.
“The estimate, roughly, to pick up four million cubic yards is $100 million,” Cosgrove said, noting that even if the sales tax increase passes, the city would have to aggressively compete for grants and other funds to reach that bar.
Hall noted the city’s budget is currently stable, but doesn’t have enough money for the restoration of the beaches.
“Our budget is there, it’s healthy,” Hall said. “This isn’t intended to be a bailout of mismanagement of funds … what we don’t have in our budget right now is extra money to do things that we haven’t done in the past.”
Cabral noted the city’s identified several pockets where they could pull sand from, but without money, none of the projects can move forward, adding that they were looking at federal funding sources as well in case the tax measure fails.
“We need money,” Cabral said, noting he had residents telling him they were bailing water out of their backyards amid the recent swells. “This is a crisis happening in real time.”
Since the swells, city leaders signed off on an emergency spend of $1 million to help shore up the coastline, and are set to receive another $1 million from the state government under a new push from State Sen. Tony Strickland.
Newport Beach Fasttracks New Sand in Months

Shortly after the swells that battered the coast earlier this year, Newport Beach leaders announced they were moving up their normal sand replenishment schedule to put around 100,000 cubic yards of new sand along the beach from the Santa Ana River.
While Supervisor Katrina Foley initially claimed the county would open up around 200,000 cubic yards of sand for the city, city spokesperson Georgia Rios clarified that while their permits allow for that, there’s only about 100,000 cubic yards of sand to pull from right now.
The project is expected to commence later this month and will likely cost the city between $1-$1.5 million according to Rios.
“Sand replenishment in West Newport typically happens each winter, but due to the anticipated El Niño storms, the City is partnering with the County to expedite this work to protect homes and the coastline,” Rios wrote in a statement. “This is normally done every year, or every other year depending on sand conditions. This year we moved it up due to El Niño.”
OC Public Works spokesperson Jamie Cargo noted that while county staff have moved the sand onto the city beaches for the past nine years, this time it would be city staff leading the charge.
On Saturday, Hall noted that cities like Newport Beach are in better shape because they set up annual replenishment programs years ago that San Clemente does not have.
“That’s the mode we need to get into,” Hall said.
Hall also pointed out that Newport Beach’s decision to develop malls and other tax generating attractions gives them more money to buy sand with, and that San Clemente’s decision to remain a smaller beach town means they have to find other ways to raise the funds.
Cabral said the city is also working to get more local leaders engaged at the beach, investing transportation dollars along the coastline instead of inland.
“If you’re asking how do you want to spend your money? This freeway, this road, this bus, or sand in San Clemente, their priorities aren’t here,” Cabral said. “We’re trying to change that.”











