Opinion

Press release

Voice of OC Collegiate News Service logo

San Clemente’s second attempt to increase sales tax for sand is set to fail after voters shot down a citizen-led initiative that appeared on November’s ballot.

It comes as a series of exceptionally high tides, known as king tides, are expected to threaten Orange County’s coastline over the next couple months and into the new year.

While Orange County coastal cities brace for king tides and a Super El Niño, San Clemente has spent several years grappling with significant sand loss, leaving portions of its shoreline increasingly vulnerable to powerful waves, coastal flooding and storm damage — especially the train tracks that run adjacent to the coastline.

The city has also grappled with funding sources for sand replenishment, looking to grants or sales tax increases to pay for projects that will get more sand on the beaches.

The ballot measure in San Clemente, placed there by residents, would have increased the sales tax by 1%. Those extra funds would have been designated half for beach projects, like sand replenishment, and half for wildfire prevention.

But according to election results from the OC Registrar of Voters, that effort is on track to fail by a fairly wide margin. Latest election tallies show about 62.5% of San Clemente voters rejected the sales tax increase, while about 37.5% of votes counted were in favor — a difference of about 7,000 votes between the two.

Cameron Cosgrove, a San Clemente resident who led the effort to get the measure on the ballot, said he was deeply disappointed by the results.

“I’m grateful to the residents who volunteered their time and worked hard to bring the measure to the voters,” he wrote in a text to Voice of OC.

“It’s now up to the City Council to lay out what the city can do, with current revenue,” he added. “Our beaches continue to erode, and San Clemente still faces a high wildfire risk. People hopefully understand we still need a plan with funding to protect our town.”

The San Clemente Pier. Credit: ANNIE LEWIS, Voice of OC

It’s not the first time the city tried to increase sales tax to get a dedicated funding source for sand, address coastal erosion and prevent the coastline from sinking into the sea.

In November 2024, voters considered a city-backed 0.5% sales tax increase intended to help fund coastal projects, including sand replenishment. Although the measure received 64.62% votes in support, it failed because the special tax required a two-thirds majority, or approximately 66.7%, to pass.

This year’s sales tax only needed a simple majority, over 50% approval, to pass.

Councilmember Zhen Wu wrote an argument in opposition for this year’s ballot measure ahead of the election, penning the argument alongside former Mayors Robert Baker and Kathy Ward.

“Voters rejected the 0.5% tax,” reads the argument in opposition. “Proponents are back with a doubled ask — without a clear plan, safeguards, or cost-benefit analysis. This measure uses most of the City’s remaining 1.5% local tax capacity, leaving little room for real emergencies.”

The measure would have increased the city’s sales tax from 7.75% to 8.75%.

“The measure failed due to a number reasons compounding: the high cost of living has been voters’ top concern in this year, and this serves as the underlying tide change against tax measures, particularly regressive sales tax increases,” Wu wrote in an email to Voice of OC. 

“The measure had no spending plan upfront and no anti-supplantation clause to make sure new revenue is not replacing things that are already covered by the general fund,” Wu continued.

Cosgrove penned the argument in support, alongside three other residents and former Mayor Tim Brown.

“I was disturbed by what I saw as an orchestrated effort by the opposition on social media to mislead residents about Measure M,” Cosgrove wrote in a text to Voice of OC. “When fake accounts and others repeat false claims, it becomes harder for residents to know what’s true and have an honest conversation.”

The swings and mural behind the bathrooms at North Beach in San Clemente on April 24, 2025. Credit: EFREM PLAWNER, Voice of OC

At the Oct. 20 San Clemente City Council meeting, officials proclaimed a new local emergency following Tropical Storm Rachel and continued the existing emergency declaration related to Hurricane Marie. 

According to the staff report presented to the council, Tropical Storm Rachel that hit in early October caused “additional coastal impacts, including further damage to the San Clemente Pier, continued beach sand loss and erosion, coastal flooding concerns, and additional protective and maintenance activities.” 

City officials and regional agencies have pursued several strategies to address the erosion problem. 

San Clemente recently received approval to restart its Sand Compatibility and Opportunistic Use Program, or SCOUP, which permits placing up to 300,000 cubic yards of compatible beach-quality sand annually across four beaches. 

The city previously placed approximately 20,000 cubic yards of sand from the Santa Ana River on North Beach, while partnerships involving the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and California State Parks have already placed more than 200,000 cubic yards of sand on San Clemente beaches.

The city’s nature-based adaptation study examined several breakwater concepts intended to reduce wave energy and protect sand already placed on the shoreline.

The train runs through San Clemente. Credit: ANNIE LEWIS, Voice of OC

As city leaders continue to grapple with coastal erosion, they won’t have a dedicated funding source from sales tax to help pay for sand replenishment and other efforts to widen the city’s beaches.

The loss of sand has raised particular concerns for the railroad tracks running along San Clemente’s coastline. Orange County transportation officials have identified continued beach loss, erosion of the railroad embankment and increased exposure to wave attack as ongoing threats to the coastal rail corridor.

California Coastal Commissioners recently approved plans for the OC Transportation Authority to bolster the train tracks running along the coast after the rail services have been shut down repeatedly in recent years due to coastal erosion. 

Transportation agency officials are looking to place 690,000 cubic yards of sand, with 240,000 cubic yards going to North Beach and Mariposa Point, and 450,000 cubic yards at San Clemente State Beach.

The Collegiate News Service is a partnership between Voice of OC and local student journalists. Contact the Collegiate News Service Editor Angelina Hicks at ahicks@voiceofoc.org

Angelina Hicks is Voice of OC’s Collegiate News Service editor, leading the newsroom’s partnership with Chapman University that gives students the chance to report on civic news across Orange County. Hicks...