Opinion

Press release

Voice of OC Collegiate News Service logo

Outgoing Tustin Mayor Austin Lumbard withdrew a heavily criticized item from the agenda after intense public backlash – a proposal that would have essentially stripped incoming Mayor Letitia Clark’s ability to appoint people to various boards. 

The move comes hours before Tuesday’s 6 p.m. city council meeting.

Lumbard and the current city council were slated to vote on a proposal that would have appointed – at the selection of Lumbard – city council members and others to serve on committees and boards such as the OC Fire Authority Board of Directors and the OC Mosquito and Vector Control District Board of Trustees.

With less than four hours before tonight’s regular meeting is set to take place, Lumbard told Voice of OC he would be withdrawing his proposed appointments despite confirmation from Tustin City Attorney David Kendig that the current city council and mayor have the legal authority to approve the appointments. 

In his Tuesday statement, Lumbard said his reasoning for offering the appointments was to ensure the various committees were able to continue their work without interruption. 

“My decision to withdraw this item is in response to the substantial misinformation and negativity surrounding this item, despite my continued concern that risk of unfilled vacancies would jeopardize the fullest representation of Tustin voices and could affect their effectiveness and continuity of services,” he wrote. 

It comes after Clark, the incoming mayor and former councilwoman, took to social media to announce Lumbard’s appointments being agendized for tonight’s meeting, saying the role of appointing representatives to different boards, committees and commissions was usually reserved for after the incoming mayor was sworn into office. 

According to Clark, the move would have broken the tradition of mayoral appointments being voted on by city council on the second council meeting of December. 

In a statement sent to Voice of OC by Clark on Tuesday, she said her concern with Lumbard’s appointments was about respecting voter’s wishes and ensuring a fair leadership transition within the city. 

“Tustin residents voted for a new mayor and a new direction. Unfortunately, this action sends the message that the outgoing administration is more interested in preserving its influence than respecting the outcome of the election,” she wrote. 

“I had hoped we could begin this new chapter with mutual respect and a shared commitment to serving our residents. Instead, before I’ve even taken the oath of office, we’re confronting an effort to limit the authority and influence of the incoming mayor.”

The appointments would have included the replacement of Lumbard on the OC Fire Authority Board of Directors with Councilman Ray Schnell and the establishment of a new Veteran’s Advisory Committee – consisting of two councilmembers, a representative from the Tustin American Legion Post 227 and the Tustin Veterans Outpost, along with three at-large veteran members. 

It would have also included the appointment of former Tustin Councilwoman and OC Board of Education Member Beckie Gomez to represent Tustin on the OC Mosquito and Vector Control Board of Trustees. 

Gomez resigned from the role of Board of Education Trustee in 2022 after a lawsuit was filed against her for serving on the education board and on city council at the same time. 

In another Tuesday statement to Voice of OC, Clark said withdrawing the agenda item was “the right thing to do,” adding that she looks forward to working with the city council on her selected appointments. 

“The public spoke and the sentiments were resounding. Although I haven’t received a clear reason of why it was placed on the agenda in the 1st place at this time, I believe this is the best response to something that did not appear fair or right, particularly in the eyes of the voters.”  

Sara Leon is a Voice of OC reporting fellow. You can reach her at admin@voiceofoc.org

Sara Leon joined Voice of OC as a summer intern in 2026 from Cal State Fullerton. Leon started in journalism at Fullerton College’s student newspaper, The Hornet, before transferring to Cal State...