OC WISE Releases New Report on Effects of Huntington Beach Desalination Plant

The following is a press release from an organization unaffiliated with Voice of OC. The views expressed here are not those of Voice of OC


August 2, 2016                                                                                              
Contact: Robert Sulnick
Scientific Report: “No Evidence that a Seafloor Infiltration Gallery (SIG) will Minimize Mortality of Marine Life at Proposed Huntington Beach Desalination Plant”
Orange, Calif. – OC WISE, a diverse, non-partisan coalition that supports the development of all forms of new, local drought-proof water for Orange County, released a scientific report today which concludes there is no scientific justification supporting the assertion that a Seafloor Infiltration Gallery (SIG) at a proposed Huntington Beach desalination plant will significantly reduce mortality of marine life. 
Mindful of the current debate over the kind of intake that should be allowed by the California Coastal Commission (SIG or screened ocean intake) at the proposed Huntington Beach desalination plant, OC WISE commissioned the Report authored by marine biology expert Dr. Daniel Cartamil, who currently holds a research position at the Scripps Institution of Oceanography in La Jolla, California.
“Given the contention over the kind of intake the project should be required to build, we commissioned the study to provide scientific input to the Commissioners in making their decision”, said Robert H. Sulnick, OC WISE’s Executive Director
An Appendix to the Report, peer-reviewed and supported by 14 marine biologists, concluded:  “Although SIG intakes are purported to reduce or eliminate [marine mortality] impacts, there is no scientific evidence whatsoever to support this assertion.” See the full report here
“Seafloor Infiltration Gallery (SIG) intakes have not been demonstrated to be effective at minimizing intake and mortality of marine life”, said marine biologist and author of the Report Daniel Cartamil.  He went onto say, “There is no scientific justification for the assertion that SIGs will eliminate impingement and entrainment [mortality] of planktonic organisms at the proposed Huntington Beach desalination plant site. In addition, the construction and operation of a SIG at this location may have extensive and deleterious impacts to benthic habitat and organisms.”
It is anticipated the Coastal Commission will consider the project, including the kind of intake required, at its September 8th meeting in Newport Beach.


Voice of OC posts press releases to provide readers with information directly from organizations. We do not edit or rewrite press releases, and encourage readers to contact the originator of a given release for more information. To submit a press release email pressreleases@voiceofoc.org
  • BeeBee.BeeLeaves


    And water cost going from $600 acre/foot to between $2200-2400 acre/foot also matters.

    Being colonized, and in bondage for 5 decades plus into the future by a foreign owned company really, really matters. Pay up suckers are not us. Bleh.

    May the door hit ya where the good Lord split ya, Poseidon misadventure. The world is large. Go elsewhere. Fukushima?


    OC-Wise is a pro-Poseidon, pro-development group. It is in Poseidon’s interest to “prove” that sub-surface intakes (infiltration galleries or slant wells) are too costly, too environmentally damaging or are otherwise infeasible. Then Poseidon will argue to the Coastal Commission that they should be allowed to have a direct ocean intake, never mind the fact that the State Water Resources Control Board has already shown that intakes kill thousands of pounds of sea life per year and has ordered all coastal power plants to cease using ocean intakes for cooling water.

  • 4Oceans

    smells like toxic green wash

  • David Zenger

    OC Wise is just a phony AstroTurf front for Poseidon, right?

    Let’s set aside the marine life issue for a moment. The Poseidon desal scheme is tax-payer insured scam to produce the most expensive water imaginable so that Rancho Mission Viejo can keep building more houses, right?