Opinion

Press release

Voice of OC Collegiate News Service logo

A proposed Nickelodeon-themed resort along Garden Grove’s Harbor Boulevard strip will be left to voters to decide its future next summer. 

City leaders voted 6-0-1 during a meeting in September to send the project to a special election on June 8, 2027 — which is projected to cost the city about $1 million. Councilmember Joe DoVinh recused himself from the vote. 

Garden Grove City Council members previously cleared the project for construction during a meeting on Sept. 13, 2022. 

Located on the corner of Harbor Boulevard and Twintree Lane, the project quickly came under legal scrutiny after hotel workers’ union Unite Here Local 11 and local activist group VietRISE filed a lawsuit against the city on Sept. 22, 2022.

The suit claimed that the city had allegedly failed to file a required environmental review for the project before construction could start.

The lawsuit was settled after the city agreed to conduct a formal environmental impact study and to either change the ordinance in accordance with the study’s findings, or to drop the project entirely.

The parties additionally agreed to drop the suit if the city agreed to make changes to the ordinance and place it on a ballot for voter consideration to allow construction to continue.

Now, Garden Grove voters are set to decide the future of the Nickelodeon hotel next summer to prevent further fallouts from the lawsuit.

“Obviously, it’s frustrating to be put in the position to have to spend this kind of money for a special election,” Mayor Stephanie Klopfenstein said at the meeting. “It’s unfortunate that this is happening at all.”

Councilmember George Brietigam spoke in support of the project’s completion but expressed concerns over the potential results of the election.

“I think if we put it on the ballot, the community will vote it down, instead of killing it here right now,” Brietigam said. 

“This money saves us. With the addition of this hotel, we can actually start looking to do some other things from the TOT tax instead of just staying in the black.”

A Transient Occupancy Tax is a tax on guests staying at hotels or short-term rentals, such as AirBNB reservations.

The current rate for Garden Grove’s Transient Occupancy Tax is 14.5%, and annually generates around $28 million in city revenue according to the city’s adopted budget.

This makes Garden Grove’s hotel tax rates one of the highest in Orange County. 

It’s only outmatched by Anaheim’s 15% hotel tax, which made $246 million last year.

For comparison, the hotel tax in the city of Fullerton is 10% per stay and generates only $3 million annually according to their budget.

Councilmember Ariana Arestegui agreed with Brietigam on the potential financial impact of the Nickelodeon hotel, but also questioned where the cost of the election was coming from. 

According to City Attorney Omar Sandoval, the election’s million-dollar price tag was requested by the Orange County Registrar of Voters.

If more election-related costs arise, it will be sent back to the city council to request more funds.

“Spending a million dollars on a special election is definitely something that none of us had in our bingo card at the beginning of the year,” Arestegui said. 

Councilmember DoVinh recused from voting, believing that both the economic and governmental costs of the election will negatively affect the future of Garden Grove.

“Our vote tonight will reverberate to the next council, and they will have to bear the consequences,” DoVinh said. “I don’t want to pass on that million-dollar liability to them.”

As of Friday evening, DoVinh was on track to lose his reelection bid.

This is not the first time DoVinh weighed in on the Nickelodeon Hotel project.

During the 2022 race for city council, the Voice of OC staff contacted all candidates with questions about housing and the hotel’s construction plans.

DoVinh called for the hotel project to be sent to a public hearing, as well as calling on Garden Grove to better address homelessness in the city.  

“We need to do more to provide long-term housing for seniors and the disabled also, while advocating for more resources for the homeless,” DoVinh said. 

Current city council members Brietigiam and Cindy Ngoc Tran were given the same questions during that questionnaire, but did not respond for comments.

DoVinh’s sentiments were also shared by hotel workers union Unite Here Local 11 and Garden Grove-based activist organization VietRISE.

“Working families across Orange County are struggling with rising rents, while seniors in mobile home parks face displacement and homelessness,” Administrative Assistant Julie Nguyen said in an email to Voice of OC.

“Little Saigon does not need more luxury hotels and resorts.”

The Collegiate News Service is a partnership between Voice of OC and local student journalists. Contact the Collegiate News Service Editor Angelina Hicks at ahicks@voiceofoc.org

Tristan Caliboso is a Chapman University student reporting for Voice of OC through the Collegiate News Service, a partnership between Voice of OC and local student journalists. Caliboso has covered...