Opinion

Press release

Voice of OC Collegiate News Service logo

Santa Ana officials are cancelling their automated license plate reader contracts and turning off their Flock cameras immediately while potentially on the hook to still pay over $482,000 collectively to two companies for the cameras.

The move makes the city the first in Orange County to end their contracts for these types of cameras in the wake of a historical election that saw all police union-backed candidates lose their election bids – including officials that approved the contracts in the first place.

It comes after many residents and local activists have raised privacy concerns about the cameras including data leaks and federal agencies accessing the cameras amid the ongoing widespread deportation raids that have hit Santa Ana hard. 

Police and some elected officials across OC have hailed automated license plate readers as a useful tool in solving crimes like car thefts and say there are safeguard policies in place aimed at preventing the misuse of the cameras.

On Tuesday, Santa Ana City Council members voted 6-0 to cancel their contracts with Flock and Motorola for automated license plate readers after Councilwoman Jessie Lopez requested a discussion on getting rid of the cameras in October.

Police union-backed Councilman Phil Bacerra, who voted to approve the contract last year and lost his reelection, was absent.

Lopez, who beat police union-backed Councilman David Penaloza in a state assembly race, said the vote means the cameras would be immediately turned off. 

“When this council approved these cameras – the system, residents were promised accountability, and tonight I think is really the first time that we have real numbers in front of us via the staff report,” she said during Tuesday’s meeting. 

“It feels like in a small way the first step towards real accountability by moving forward and following the steps of other jurisdictions that have also canceled this contract.”

Lopez requested a discussion on reviewing their automated license plate cameras after an August Inadvertent article based on public records reported a Northern California fusion center accessed Santa Ana’s cameras on behalf of federal agencies. 

According to a staff report, Santa Ana police stopped sharing access to the cameras with the fusion center. 

The center conducted over 150,000 searches across Santa Ana’s Flock and Motorola automated license plate reader systems in a roughly one year time span. 

The discussion also comes as a new progressive majority is on track to take control of the city council including Mayor-elect Dan Shimell, Councilwoman-elect Sandra De Anda and Councilwoman-elect Isuri Ramos – all of whom have opposed Flock Cameras.

Penaloza, who voted in favor of the contracts last year, successfully called on staff to look into the legality of banning privately owned automated license plate readers. 

“They’re still going to exist in our city, and our residents are still going to be captured by these cameras on private property and these are properties and equipment that we have no control or say over,” he said.

Police union-backed Mayor Valerie Amezcua, who lost her reelection bid to a newcomer and voted in favor of the contracts last year, said banning businesses from using this type of technology will drive them out of the city. 

“What’s going to happen is we’re going to lose businesses. They’re going to leave the city and they’re going to go to Costa Mesa or Garden Grove or Tustin, which is going to hurt us dearly as a city,” she said, before voting in favor of cancelling the contracts and supporting Penaloza’s request. 

“We will start to lose revenue very quickly when businesses are told that in the city of Santa Ana, the Home Depots, the Walmarts, the Targets, the malls, the restaurants, all of the above, and you say to them, ‘you cannot have those cameras on your property, even though you put it there for your protection and for the success of your business.’”

Lopez questioned if it was feasible to dictate whether business can have automated license plate readers or not but welcomed city staff looking into the issue

Santa Ana isn’t the city in OC having a reckoning with automated license plate readers.

Fullerton officials became the first in the county this year to temporarily turn off their automated license plate readers for six months after a host of residents raised privacy and mass surveillance concerns about their Flock cameras.

In the summer, officials in Costa Mesa – a city neighboring Santa Ana – decided to keep their contract for Flock cameras and called on staff to renegotiate it to tighten rules on data accessibility after a former police officer used the cameras to stalk his wife, an ex-girlfriend and his romantic rivals.

Santa Ana’s Automated License Plate Readers

According to a staff report, about 24 stationary Flock Cameras were installed in August 2025 across the city and another 24 Motorola stationary automated license plate readers were installed around the end of 2025.

From the start of September last year to the end of September 2026, Santa Ana Police made nearly 40,000 searches across both their Flock and Motorola systems while other agencies made over 3.6 million searches. 

Between the start of April and the end of September, use of the cameras led to 20 arrests and to two missing people being found. 

The two automated license plate reader contracts city council members narrowly approved in May 2025 – costing a combined roughly $700,000 – do not let city officials end the contracts without cause.

The Motorola contract has a 5-year term and the city is still on the hook to pay over $351,000 to satisfy the agreement. The Flock contract has a 3-year term and the city owes over $131,000 to cover the remaining two years.  

Ending the Motorola contract early could result in the city having to pay the company the remaining over $351,000 immediately.

The financial obligation remains while the city continues to face a structural deficit that some current elected officials hope a voter approved tax measure will help address. 

The initiative, dubbed Measure N, will indefinitely keep a 1.5% sales tax increase that was supposed to decrease in a couple of years before ending in 2039.

As of 5 p.m. Tuesday, about 67% of voters were in favor of Measure N. There were over 70,700 votes counted so far in the race.

Councilwoman Thai Viet Phan, who voted last year to approve the automated license plate readers contract, called on staff to talk to the two companies about waiving the fees. 

“I don’t think at this time Flock or Motorola is looking for any additional negative press.”

Hosam Elattar is a Voice of OC/ Report For America reporter covering Anaheim & North Orange County, food insecurity, housing & homelessness, the Arab & Muslim American community and education. Elattar...