Opinion

Press release

Voice of OC Collegiate News Service logo

Orange County supervisors opted not to induct the county’s most famous cowboy into their hall of fame on Tuesday amid concerns over John Wayne’s past comments about race and sex. 

The debate over Wayne sparked a broader discussion over what Orange County’s values are, what they’ve been and what bar people have to meet to be recognized by the county. 

Wayne was one of Hollywood’s biggest stars from the 1930s to the 1970s, starring in a series of westerns and war movies, winning an Oscar for True Grit in 1970, and he spent the last years of his life living in Orange County. 

But his legacy is a complicated one. 

One of the biggest controversies surrounding Wayne was stirred up this week, centering on his comments from a Playboy interview in 1971 where he commented about his support for white supremacy. 

“I believe in white supremacy until the blacks are educated to a point of responsibility. I don’t believe in giving authority and positions of leadership and judgment to irresponsible people,” Wayne said at the time. 

The John Wayne Statue stands at the John Wayne Airport in Santa Ana on Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026. Credit: IZABELLA ORTIZ, Voice of OC

Wayne also faced criticism over his decision not to serve in the military during WWII, with historians noting he was booed when he visited troops overseas because he chose not to enlist unlike movie stars Clark Gable and Jimmy Stewart. 

In recent years, there’s been ongoing talk about removing Wayne’s name from Orange County’s airport, which is Santa Ana. In 2016, state assembly members also backed away from establishing a John Wayne Day. 

This week, County Supervisor Don Wagner reignited the debate – proposing Wayne for Orange County’s Hall of Fame. 

After acknowledging Wayne’s controversial statements in the Playboy magazine, Wagner said the actor still merited recognition as an OC icon, adding that if the county was unwilling to accept Wayne, they’d have to consider disowning figures such as George Washington and Abraham Lincoln. 

“Certainly John Wayne’s legacy writ large is not what you find in one Playboy magazine article where John Wayne said some things that clang very definitely off the modern ear,” Wagner said. “To suggest John Wayne was racist and a white supremacist is a little odd given his history.” 

Wagner then contrasted Wayne against other historical figures, saying that if only perfect people were honored they would have to drop support for figures such as Winston Churchill, Martin Luther King Jr., the Kennedy brothers and Cesar Chavez. 

“He’s (Wayne) remembered for embodying values that reflect America. Keeping alive that memory, that’s the legacy. Not dumb comments in a playboy magazine,” Wagner said. “We can take the good and condemn the bad and when you are making that balancing test George Washington passes the test, Abraham Lincoln passes the test, Cesar Chavez passes the test, John Wayne passes the test.”

The boot of John Wayne, “American Legend,” is engraved on his statue located on the arrivals floor at John Wayne Airport in Santa Ana on Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026. Credit: IZABELLA ORTIZ, Voice of OC

Supervisor Vicente Sarmiento followed that up by immediately apologizing to the public and to county employees for Wagner’s comments, calling them “a very tough thing to hear.” 

“It’s not a single statement or moment of time,” Sarmiento said. “There is a chronicle of documented history of this person’s comments.”

Supervisor Janet Nguyen didn’t weigh in on Wayne’s history, but shot back at commenters who suggested it was racist to support Wagner’s nomination of Wayne. 

“You might have your opinion on it but my goal here is to support my colleague’s nomination,” Nguyen said. “To stand here and call me racist crosses the line.” 

While none of the commenters explicitly called Wagner or Nguyen racist, two speakers from the Orange County branch of the NAACP objected to Wayne’s inclusion in the Hall of Fame and asked Wagner and Nguyen to state if they were opposed to white supremacy. 

“This nomination raises a fundamental question about the values we choose to honor and the message we send to the communities we serve,” said Deirdre Harris, the president of the local NAACP. “Do you reject John Wayne’s expressed belief in white supremacy? Are you prepared to defend him and honor him despite his belief? The people of Orange County deserve to know. Your nomination demands an explanation.” 

The John Wayne Statue stands at the John Wayne Airport in Santa Ana on Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026. Credit: IZABELLA ORTIZ, Voice of OC

Supervisor Doug Chaffee, the deciding vote on the issue who’s leaving office in a couple of weeks, abstained. 

 “I don’t want to be the deciding vote,” Chaffee said. “I’m very torn between recognizing those who would like to honor him and the unfortunate comments that were made.” 

“Which is a lot like a no vote,” Wagner said.

“That’s the result,” Chaffee said. “Yes.” 

Noah Biesiada serves as Voice of OC’s county reporter, covering the county board of supervisors and the $9 billion government they oversee.  Biesiada started as an intern in July 2019, helping launch...